|
Reader Comments
My thoughts have often gone back to the reflections and words you offer. The subtitle, "Cherishing Christianity without Its Exclusive Claims," is an excellent summary of your thoughts. . . . Thank you for being so honest and revealing questions shared by many. This gives all of us courage to live fully, honoring all our questions.
Regina Birchem, Irwin, PA (near Pittsburgh)
I'm about half way through it at this point and have enjoyed every word you've written. As a person who was raised Catholic, your book has been a great source of ideas . . . THANKS. You have done a wonderful service for all people like me, who have had a million questions about their Catholic faith and the many inconsistencies that seem to permeate the dogma. . . . your way of reconciling all the differences offers a new way for me to articulate the many questions and beliefs that have kept me always feeling like a Catholic, even when I feel like a hypocrite to everyone else in the Catholic boat of beliefs . . ."
I have already begun to talk with my friends about your book and have read sections to them. . . . I am planning on purchasing books for these people. Most of the conversations with these friends have been enjoyable, however, there have been some tense moments as we discussed the topics. Still, we keep talking.
This afternoon I read through the section on Jesus (Chapter 6, I think) and found your perceptions extremely interesting. I can hardly wait to talk with my friends about it.
Jim from Stillwater, the Worrying Warrior
I absolutely loved it! It was the first time I read what I had always been thinking.
You helped to clarify so many thoughts and incongruities I had always felt growing up Catholic.
Your thoughts and feelings made me feel so less alone in understanding my faith.
Your words helped me understand how my faith and religion can co-exist in my heart and practice.
My mother shared another opinion column of yours with me this weekend regarding Islam and the prejudices currently held by many Christians/Americans.
It reminded me that I had always wanted to tell you what an impact your book had on me.
I am so grateful you wrote the book.
I also appreciate that you continue to use your words to express your faith and beliefs.
Your courage is admirable!
Natascha Smrekar, Guthrie, Minnesota
Last week I could read your book and really THINK while reading, giving each page as much attention as it deserved. WHAT A REWARD I RECEIVED!
My first thoughts were those of being uplifted, being happy, being relieved and being certain that I have thought the same thoughts that exist in your book for YEARS, but had no idea how to express them...or even that they COULD be expressed. The words that you offer to identify what most people call "God" and your rejection of the He/Him pronoun released me into a realm of unlimited beauty and peace. Yes, I catch myself saying He/Him, but I am immediately reminded that I no longer have that box (prison?) around me and joyfully move out to embrace this Higher Power. Please know that just reading the book was life-giving to me...and a confirmation of things that had run niggly-wiggly through my mind and had literally terrified me.
Chapter 5 was marvelous!! I found myself smiling through each of its pages and constantly nodding my head as if I were saying YES, YES, YES!! And even before I got to Chapter 5 I was saying, "HOW does she pray"? I would like to explore that further with you as would I also like to explore the concept of evil. But first I must reread many pages and delight again in the knowledge that I know a person such as you and that you have led me to a greater understanding of my SELF.
Carol Landkamer, Maple Grove, MN
Jeanette did such detailed research. I especially found so much truth and direction in the second half.
The entire research effort and her conclusions from the works of others and her individual mining and
melting of facts with her beliefs and findings are just remarkable. Her book is one that should be on
the reading list of all our Catholic friends.
Dennis W. Horan - Northfield, MN
I just finished "God is not Three Guys in the Sky." It's great, and I thank
you for writing it. After a lifetime of nervous heretical doubting I
finally feel okay with questions.
Chris Scott, St. Cloud.
I've
forwarded it on to my friends here in Michigan. I recommended your book to
them and they ordered
God is Not
Three Guys in the Sky
and LOVE it! We agree with what you have written and can hardly wait to
discuss it! I'm not quite through with it and have to admit that I marked it
up on the train by underlining favorite or key sentences. You've done such a
fantastic work.
Kathleen
Herrick
You have substantiated and put into print, that which I have always
believed. Thank you for your insatiable hunger for the truth.
Scott
Thompson,
St. Cloud
I can hardly put the book down! I
love it.
Catherine L. Young, Indianapolis, IN
Jeanette, it's the most applicable
spiritual work I've read since M.Scott Peck five years ago. I've read some
Carl Jung and you do him proud –very clear. I've read Michael Morewood
–you’re smoother and more personal. I've read John Shelby Spong –you’re
more Catholic. I've read Matthew Fox and you’re more concise.
For me as a cradle Catholic also, it's a
radical, life-changing, soul-enhancing book. Congratulations!
Ron Ohmann, former physician and St. Cloud Times columnist
|
|
Just starting your book . . . It’s very honest and thought-provoking. Even in the book’s controversy and intellectual presentation, your love shines through your words.
I do have a Christian background, being raised in a fundamentalist Christian home (lots of dos and don’ts!). In fact, several of my relatives were ministers. However, I knew at the age of 12 . . . It’s always a treat to read others’ process of discovery—through thought, reasoning, feeling, mystical experiences, and so on—that their beliefs differ from religious decree! For many years, I felt so betrayed by the church and Jesus that I turned my back on them completely. Only in the last five years have I been able to explore the history of Jesus and the early Christians. Your book will be an informative addition to my exploration!
I admire your courage to be a bridge, to share the truth of your being, and to light a pathway for others to question and examine and share the truth of theirs! I’m finding that I read your book in short sections and then must give them time to digest. It’s as if I’m crossing a field of hidden landmines to reach a deeply desired destination and must often pause to get my bearings in order to weave among them. Thanks for the invitation to explore Christianity again after spending so many years rejecting it! Namaste,
Beth Blevins http://sacredweb.blogspot.com/
I am in the middle of your book God is Not Three Guys in the Sky … and I have to admit that, although I am still quite attached to the patriarchal aspects of Christianity, I have really found your wonderful book to be refreshing and enlightening.
My wife and I actually argued who got to read it first! This book will be on my mind for quite a while, and I can't wait to talk to other people who have read it.
I can only imagine the courage it took to write and publish this book in the Land of Lutherans and Catholics here in central Minnesota.
Also, I want to thank you for your craftsmanship as a writer -- your writing is clear and sharp and a pleasure to read. Thank you for this amazing book!
Mike Sawin, St. Cloud Times writer from Cold Spring
I don't know if you realize how much of a blessing your book is to someone like me, as well as to my wife. You validated our experience and empowered us to go forward without looking back. Like the person who wrote the review on your website, yours has set me free in a way that theirs did not. . . . I found it to be very spiritual.
Gary Egeberg, Edina, MN
The foundations of patriarchy are trembling and those who benefit by its structure will be extremely threatened. Please keep on writing. Your work is prophetic and you are a truthsayer. We need you.
Mary Frances Smith, Long Lake, MN
. . . absolutely loving your book!!!
Denise Koerber, St. Cloud, MN
I took along the copy of your book and
read out loud 5 chapters! T. said it was easy to listen to and I found it
easy to read. And she found a lot of sense in it even though she, too, may
never have thought it through in those terms or been able to articulate it.
The same is true for many of us.
What I find particularly interesting is
that you paid attention to the inconsistencies that others too readily
dismissed and pursued them as a study in themselves and made order out of
them. (That’s the whole basis of chaos theory as I understand it. Those
little anomalies in science are too readily dismissed but are really the
door or key to whole other realms of order inherent in the big picture. And
they often supply a background or larger frame for the issue under study.)
So thanks for your willingness to make yourself vulnerable in behalf of the
larger truths. I can’t help but think many people will find the book a
source of insight, relief, and a way of retaining Christian identity even in
the face of such problematic issues. Great job!
Mariterese Woida, OSB
I began reading your book, printing out
the first chapter, and repaired to my perch by the window. I love it! And
I want to pore over the rest of it. Today I will take the first 11 pages
to my dad to read because only yesterday we were talking about how the
precarious belief system of the Catholic Church is very like an enormous
house of cards; and if we tug away even a single card from the flimsy
structure the whole thing could collapse. The simplicity and clarity of
your writing is delightful. And very helpful.
Peter Fandel, St. Cloud
I started reading it and was just
reading along, when I decided to go back and make notes in the margins . .
. This is a very important work . . . Thank you for the long labor of love
for women and men everywhere.
Yvonne Sexton, St. Cloud
I have the book,
God is Not
Three Guys in the Sky, and am currently reading it. Very
interesting. It brings up the point that the kind of spiritual questioning
she is doing is also going on within the church by Catholic scholars and was
encouraged by Popes Pius XII and John XXIII at Vatican II.
Laura Stanley, St. Cloud, MN.
|